The Courtesy Check: score one object yourself
The Courtesy Check turns the published rubric into questions about one specific object: the thing in your hand, in your cart, or in your closet. It uses the same six pillars, the same weights, and the same three caps described in how we score, Courtesy Score version 1.1. Every question asks about something you can check by hand, in a manual, or with the maker. Pillar questions take Yes, Partly, No, or Don't know; the three cap questions take Yes, No, or Don't know.
Don't know is an honest answer, never a zero. The check leaves those questions out of the math and works out how far they could still move the result. It shows a number only when the open questions could not push the result into a different band; otherwise it shows the range and three unanswered questions from the most heavily weighted pillars.
The Quick Check asks one question per pillar and gives a triage. The Full Check asks all thirty, and the Full Check is the score. Nothing you answer here is saved, sent, or counted: the check runs entirely on this page, and reloading it clears every answer.
Choose a check
First, the three findings that cap a score
A confirmed Yes to any of these sets a ceiling that no other answer can lift, and when more than one applies, the strictest ceiling holds. Don't know never sets one, because a cap fires only on positive knowledge.
Is the battery or other energy store glued or soldered in, with no documented way to replace it?
A Yes sets a ceiling of 40. Answer No if it has no battery.
Is it true that no spare part of any kind is sold for it?
A Yes sets a ceiling of 55. Answer No if even one part, such as a gasket, a strap, or a cable, is on sale.
Does its main job depend on a remote server that you do not control?
A Yes sets a ceiling of 70. Answer No if it has no app, no account, and no network feature.
The pillar questions
Answer what you can. Yes counts 2 points, Partly 1, and No 0, and each pillar is scored out of 10 from its Yes, Partly, and No answers. A pillar with no usable answer drops out and the other weights renormalize, exactly as in the score tables on the category pages. In the Quick Check, each pillar shows its one triage question.
Materials & construction25%
Is it made of one material rather than layers glued together?
Are the joints stitched, screwed, bolted, riveted or welded rather than glued?
Is the part that takes the wear thicker than it strictly needs to be?
Is the hardware metal everywhere it takes a load?
Can the finish be renewed — waxed, oiled, repainted, re-seasoned?
Repairability25%
Does it open with ordinary tools, without prying it apart?
Are the fasteners standard and reusable rather than one-shot rivets, clips or glue?
Is there a free repair guide for it that anyone can read?
Is the part most likely to break also the easiest one to reach?
Would a repair leave you with something you would still want to keep?
Parts & consumables20%
Does the maker say which parts wear out?
Can you buy those parts today?
Does the maker publish how many years it will keep selling them?
Do parts arrive in days rather than months?
Is the part a standard size you could buy from someone else?
Independence15%
Does it do its main job with no account, no app and no internet?
Is there no update that could switch it off or take a feature away?
Does it run on ordinary power, ordinary batteries, or none at all?
Could you replace the battery yourself, if it has one?
Are its plugs, threads and fittings standard sizes?
Third-party service10%
Is there a trade that fixes this kind of thing — cobbler, tailor, watchmaker, bike shop, repair café?
Can that trade get the parts without the maker's permission?
Does using an independent repairer leave everything you rely on intact?
Is it common enough that used parts turn up second-hand?
Is there a written guide or video showing the repair?
Guarantee & conduct5%
Is the warranty written down, in years?
Can you read how to make a claim before you buy?
Does the maker publish what the warranty does not cover?
Do owners report that the maker actually honored it?
Does the maker sell parts to people whose warranty has run out?
Your result
Quick Check triage
No result yet
Nothing is scored yet, so this object could land anywhere from Disposable to Lifetime. Answer any pillar question you can check to start narrowing it.
Answer these next
- Materials & construction: Are the joints stitched, screwed, bolted, riveted or welded rather than glued?
- Repairability: Is there a free repair guide for it that anyone can read?
- Parts & consumables: Can you buy those parts today?
This is a triage from six questions. The Full Check is the score.